Steve Harris
  • Home
  • About
  • Courses
  • Research
  • Other Sites
  • Contact
  • Condemned to Repeat It

Brexit

9/14/2020

3 Comments

 
I do regret not having started this blog a year or so ago when the Great British Brexit Baking Show was still running. But all is not lost, the “sceptered isle” is managing to extend its self-flagellation.

Our story so far involves the three worst prime ministers in recent British history:
  • David Cameron, who cravenly agreed to hold the 2016 referendum on leaving the EU (bad enough) and then authorized a proposition which failed to include a sensible ‘check-step’ of a confirmatory vote once a deal had been negotiated, likely because the Tories were so smug about winning. Oops.
  • Theresa May, brought in to implement the referendum decision in which she did not believe, who lacked the courage to admit that there was no good deal and bumbled and mumbled along for 2 ½  years, when she finally gave up, only to be succeeded last year by…
  • Boris Johnson, the ill-combed Trumpian knock-off, who promised to “get Brexit done;” which he did by dissembling, flip-flopping, and de facto ceding Northern Ireland to the Irish and breaking up the “United" Kingdom.

The deal that Boris finally signed and ramrodded through Parliament allowed for Brexit to be declared “done”, leaving aside the implementation and writing of the post-Brexit trade deal with the EU (40+% of British trade). Johnson’s bombastic and confrontational negotiating style (also paralleling his American confrere) has, unsurprisingly, left the EU cold, despite his raffish charm and occasional latinisms.

The upshot is that with just over three months to go until implementation day, there is no prospect of a deal; with dire consequences for British consumers and companies, threats to the structure of Irish/Northern Irish society and economy, and aggravating disruptions for the Europeans.

So, Boris and gang decide to force the issue, in a manner reminiscent of a kidnapper telling the police hostage negotiator “Give me what I want or I’ll shoot,” all while holding the gun to his own head. This month they announced their implementation plan which would entail reneging on the deal (i.e. signed treaty) with the EU; an act which (as a minister confessed to Parliament) would constitute a breach of international law.

The exasperated Europeans would be well justified in letting the Brits go [hang] themselves. It’s unlikely the Tories in Parliament will stand up to Boris any more than Mitch McConnell and friends have stood up for traditional Republican values trampled by Trump. So much for the “rule of law” from the “mother of parliaments.” We will have to see how Boris extracts himself from this one. It can’t end well; it’s either bad or worse.

The “rule of law” is an essential trope advanced to preserve public order, usually for the benefit of the incumbent power structure. It is no wonder that is has been central to British culture for centuries, nor that Britain promoted the concept internationally as part of its global dominance in the 18C-20C. It is a mark of Britain’s decline that such a tenet has become expendable.

I am reminded of Churchill’s remarks 80 years ago, facing the Battle of Britain and the Nazi’s likely invasion of the island, in which he said: “Let us therefore brace ourselves to our duties, and so bear ourselves, that if the British Empire and its Commonwealth last for a thousand years, men will still say, ‘This was their finest hour.’"

Well, 1940 was; even if the Empire collapsed a generation later. Now the flip-side. The Brits’ inability to come to terms with their diminished status/power/role resulting from that collapse fed the nihilism that led to Brexit and to this “unfinest” hour of imperial history. Soon it will become apparent that Brexit will be a classic, the stupidest decision taken by a major power since Hitler gratuitously declared war on the US in 1941 (now, that would be an interesting competition!). Britain’s slide from global hegemony to “special relationship,” to also-ran is not yet complete, but it was disguised by being integrated into Europe. Alas, a collapsed soufflé will not win any prizes on the Baking Contest.


3 Comments
Jack saunders
9/14/2020 09:50:43 pm

What happens when a “done” populist caper like Brexit is quietly undone to the satisfaction of the corporate set? Do the Pops whimper they’re sorry they were bad, and won’t do it again? Or do they react some other way? We are about to have a similar “never mind” hour over immigration enforcement. The otherwise-minded could be inconsolable, and armed.

Reply
Gretchen G
9/15/2020 04:13:54 am

This was a good read. My only quibble: is Johnson really a Trumpian-knockoff or his own British brand?

Reply
Trevor Getz
9/15/2020 07:38:12 am

To some degree, both the US and Britain seem to be suffering from having 17th/18th century governments that cannot cope with a 21st century situations. Not that that is a sufficient explanation, but one wonders what a 21st century government should look like. Decisive as China, but democratic? Smaller?

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Condemned to Repeat It --
    Musings on history, society, and the world.

    I don't actually agree with Santayana's famous quote, but this is my contribution to my version of it: "Anyone who hears Santayana's quote is condemned to repeat it."

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020

      Sign up for alerts when there's a new post

      Enter your email address and click 'subscribe.'
    Subscribe

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly